森林与径流关系研究进展

doi:10.11707/j.1001-7488.20190717

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 森林与径流的关系一直是林学、生态学以及水文学领域研究的难点和热点问题，至今依然存在较大争议。全世界开展了一个多世纪的集水区观测试验，也呈现出截然不同的观测结果。本文系统梳理世界上不同地区广泛开展的基于单独/配对集水区试验的森林与径流关系的研究结果，探讨森林与径流关系的争论观点和争议来源，指出未来应加强的研究方面：1）开展大尺度、多尺度耦合与精细化研究；2）开展跨站点、跨区域整合研究；3）注重过程、机理及模型模拟研究；4）加强多学科交叉、多方法比较的系统性研究。

关键词: 植被变化, 径流, 集水区, 生态水文学

Abstract: The effects of forest cover change on water yield, a hotspot as well as a difficult issue in the fields of forestry, ecology and hydrology, still exist great debate. Observations of numerous watershed experiments that have been conducted for a century throughout the world also vary greatly and remain controversial. Here, based on the observations of globally published paired-watershed experimental and the time-trend result, we comprehensively presented the divergent opinions on the effects of forest cover change on water yield and analyzed the potential underlying mechanism. After that, we further summarized four aspects which need to be emphasized in future studies:1) to develop carbon and water coupling research at multiple scales; 2) to develop multiple sites and cross-regional integration research; 3) to concentrate on hydrological and ecological processes, mechanism and modeling; 4) to strengthen the cross-penetration and integration of different disciplines and technical fields studies.

Key words: vegetation cover change, runoff, watershed, ecohydrology

中图分类号:

S715

刘效东, 刘佩伶, 戴雨航, 莫其锋, 林浩娟, 李吉跃, 张倩媚, 陈修治. 森林与径流关系研究进展[J]. 林业科学, 2019, 55(7): 155-162.

Liu Xiaodong, Liu Peiling, Dai Yuhang, Mo Qifeng, Lin Haojuan, Li Jiyue, Zhang Qianmei, Chen Xiuzhi. Research Advances in Forest-Runoff Relationship[J]. Scientia Silvae Sinicae, 2019, 55(7): 155-162.

参考文献

陈华,杨阳,王伟. 2016.基于文献计量分析我国生态水文学研究现状及热点.冰川冻土, 38(3):769-775.
(Chen H, Yang Y, Wang W. 2016. The eco-hydrology in China analyzed based on bibliometric:domestic research status and hot spots. Journal of Glaciology and Geocryology, 38(3):769-775.)
程国栋,赵传燕,王瑶. 2011.内陆河流域森林生态系统生态水文过程研究.地球科学进展, 26(11):1125-1130.
(Cheng G D, Zhao C Y, Wang Y. 2011. Advances in research of ecological and hydrological processes in the forest ecosystem in Inland River Basin of the arid regions, China. Advances in Earth Science, 26(11):1125-1130.)
傅伯杰,刘世梁. 2002.长期生态研究中的若干重要问题及趋势.应用生态学报, 13(4):476-480.
(Fu B J, Liu S L. 2002. Problems and trends of long-term ecological research. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 13(4):476-480.)
黄志刚,欧阳志云,李锋瑞,等. 2009.基于集水区法的森林生态系统影响径流研究进展.世界林业研究, 22(3):36-41.
(Huang Z G, Ouyang Z Y, Li F R, et al. 2009. Progress in the effects of forest ecosystem on runoff based on forest catchment. World Forestry Research, 22(3):36-41.)
李昌哲,郭卫东. 1986.森林植被水源涵养效益的研究.林业科学, 22(1):22-27.
(Li C Z, Guo W D. 1986. A study on the effect of protecting water source of forest vegetation. Scientia Silvae Sinicae, 22(1):22-27.)
李峰平,章光新,董李勤. 2013.气候变化对水循环与水资源的影响研究综述.地理科学, 33(4):457-464.
(Li F P, Zhang G X, Dong L Q. 2013. Studies for impact of climate change on hydrology and water resources. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 33(4):457-464.)
李广毅. 1987.美国森林集水区研究进展.陕西林业科技, 2(1):58-60.
(Li G Y. 1987. Advance of forest watershed research in U.S.A. Journal of Northwest Forestry University, 2(1):58-60.)
李文华,何永涛,杨丽韫. 2001.森林对径流影响研究的回顾与展望.自然资源学报, 16(5):398-406.
(Li W H, He Y T, Yang L Y. 2001. A summary and perspective of forest vegetation impacts on water yield. Journal of Natural Resources, 16(5):398-406.)
刘昌明,曾燕. 2002.植被变化对产水量影响的研究.中国水利, (10):112-117.
(Liu C M, Zeng Y. 2002. Research on impact of vegetation change to water generation. China Water Resources, (10):112-117.)
刘菊秀,李跃林,刘世忠,等. 2013.气温上升对模拟森林生态系统影响实验的介绍.植物生态学报, 37(6):558-565.
(Liu J X, Li Y L, Liu S Z, et al. 2013. An introduction to an experimental design for studying effects of air temperature rise on model forest ecosystems. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 37(6):558-565.)
刘效东,乔玉娜,周国逸. 2011.土壤有机质对土壤水分保持及其有效性的控制作用.植物生态学报, 35(12):1209-1218.
(Liu X D, Qiao Y N, Zhou G Y. 2011. Controlling action of soil organic matter on soil moisture retention and its availability. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 35(12):1209-1218.)
石培礼,李文华. 2001.森林植被变化对水文过程和径流的影响效应.自然资源学报, 16(5):481-487.
(Shi P L, Li W H. 2001. Influence of forest cover change on hydrological process and watershed runoff. Journal of Natural Resources, 16(5):481-487.)
孙阁,张志强,周国逸,等. 2007.森林流域水文模拟模型的概念、作用及其在中国的应用.北京林业大学学报, 29(3):178-184.
(Sun G, Zhang Z Q, Zhou G Y, et al. 2007. Forest watershed hydrological simulation models:concepts, use and application problems in China. Journal of Beijing Forestry University, 29(3):178-184.)
孙惠南. 2001.近20年来关于森林作用研究的进展.自然资源学报, 16(5):407-412.
(Sun H N. 2001. Progress of the research on the role of the forest during the past 20 years. Journal of Natural Resources, 16(5):407-412.)
王礼先,张志强. 1998.森林植被变化的水文生态效应研究进展.世界林业研究, 11(6):14-23.
(Wang L X, Zhang Z Q. 1998. Advances in the study of ecohydrological effects from vegetation changes. World Forestry Research, 11(6):14-23.)
王金叶,车克钧. 1998.祁连山森林复合流域径流规律研究.水土保持学报, 4(1):22-27.
(Wang J Y, Che K J. 1998. Runoff-produced laws of complex forest watershed in Qianlian mountain. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 4(1):22-27.)
王彦辉,金旻,于澎涛. 2004.我国与森林植被和水资源有关的环境问题及研究趋势.林业科学研究, 16(6):739-747.
(Wang Y H, Jin M, Yu P T. 2004. The environment problems related with forest vegetation and water resources in China and future research requirements. Forest Research, 16(6):739-747.)
魏晓华,李文华,周国逸,等. 2005.森林与径流关系——一致性和复杂性.自然资源学报, 20(5):761-770.
(Wei X H, Li W H, Zhou G Y, et al. 2005. Forests and streamflow-Consistence and complexity. Journal of Natural Resources, 20(5):761-770.)
杨大文,雷慧闽,丛振涛. 2010.流域水文过程与植被相互作用研究现状评述.水利学报, 41(10):1142-1149.
(Yang D W, Lei H M, Cong Z T. 2010. Overview of the research status in interaction between hydrological processes and vegetation in catchment. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 41 (10):1142-1149.)
于静洁,刘昌明. 1989.森林水文学研究综述.地理研究, 8(1):88-98.
(Yu J J, Liu C M. 1989. A review on forest hydrology study. Geographical Research, 8(1):88-98.)
余新晓. 2013.森林生态水文研究进展与发展趋势.应用基础与工程科学学报, 21(3), 391-402.
(Yu X X. 2013. A review on forest eco-hydrology research progress and development tendency. Journal of Basic Science and Engineering, 21(3), 391-402.)
张志强,余新晓,张玉涛,等. 2003.森林对水文过程影响研究进展.应用生态学报, 14(1):113-116.
(Zhang Z Q, Yu X X, Zhang Y T. et al. 2003. Advance in researches on the effect of forest on hydrological process. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 14(1):113-116.)
中野秀章. 1983.森林水文学.李云森,译.北京:中国林业出版社.
(Hideo Nagano. 1983. Forest hydrology. Translated by Li Y S. Beijing:China Forestry Publishing House.)
周国逸. 1997.生态系统水热原理及其应用.北京:气象出版社.
(Zhou G Y. 1997. Principles and applications of water and heat in eco system. Beijing:Meteorological Press.)
周国逸,张德强,李跃林,等. 2017.长期监测与创新研究阐明森林生态系统功能形成过程与机理.中国科学院院刊, 32(9):1036-1046.
(Zhou G Y, Zhang D Q, Li Y L, et al. 2017. Long-term monitoring and innovative research to illustrate the process and mechanism of forest ecosystem function. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 32(9):1036-1046.)
Andréassian V. 2004. Waters and forests:from historical controversy to scientific debate. Journal of Hydrology, 291(1/2):1-27.
Bárcena T G, Kiær L P, Vesterdal L, et al. 2014. Soil carbon stock change following afforestation in Northern Europe:a meta-analysis. Global Change Biology, 20(8):2393-2405.
Boggs J, Sun G, McNulty S. 2016. Effects of timber harvest on water quantity and quality in small watersheds in the Piedmont of North Carolina. Journal of Forestry, 114(1):27-40.
Bosch J M, Hewlett J D. 1982. A review of catchment experiments to determine the effect of vegetation changes on water yield and evapotranspiration. Journal of Hydrology, 55(1/4):3-23.
Brown A E, Zhang L, Mcmahon T A, et al. 2005. A review of paired catchment studies for determining changes in water yield resulting from alterations in vegetation. Journal of Hydrology, 310(1/4):28-61.
Buttle J M, Metcalfe R A. 2000. Boreal forest disturbance and streamflow response, northeastern Ontario. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 57(1):5-18.
Ceballos-Barbancho A, Enrique M, Miguel Á L, et al. 2008. Water resources and environmental change in a Mediterranean environment:the south-west sector of the Duero river basin (Spain). Journal of Hydrology, 351(1):126-138.
Chang M. 2012. Forest hydrology:an introduction to water and forests (third edition). New York:CRC press.
Chen X Z, Liu X D, Zhou G Y, et al. 2015a. 50-year evapotranspiration declining and potential causations in subtropical Guangdong Province, southern China. Catena, 128:185-194.
Chen Y P, Wang K B, Lin Y S, et al. 2015b. Balancing green and grain trade. Nature Geoscience, 8(10):739.
Cuo L, Giambelluca T W, Ziegler A D. 2011. Lumped parameter sensitivity analysis of a distributed hydrological model within tropical and temperate catchments. Hydrological Processes, 25(15):2405-2421.
Du E, Link T E, Gravelle J A, et al. 2014. Validation and sensitivity test of the distributed hydrology soil-vegetation model (DHSVM) in a forested mountain watershed. Hydrological processes, 28(26):6196-6210.
Fu B J, Wang S, Liu Y, et al. 2017. Hydrogeomorphic ecosystem responses to natural and anthropogenic changes in the Loess Plateau of China. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, 45:223-243.
Huang M B, Zhang L, Gallichand J. 2003. Runoff responses to afforestation in a watershed of the Loess Plateau, China. Hydrological Processes, 17(13):2599-2609.
Hibbert A R. 1965. Forest treatment effects on water yield. New York:Pergamon Press.
Hornbeck J W, Martin C W, Eagar C. 1997. Summary of water yield experiments at Hubbard Brook Experimental Forest, New Hampshire. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 27(12):2043-2052.
Lewis D, Singer M J, Dahlgren R A, et al. 2000. Hydrology in a California oak woodland watershed:a 17-year study. Journal of Hydrology, 240(1):106-117.
Li Q, Wei X H, Zhang M F, et al. 2017. Forest cover change and water yield in large forested watersheds:a global synthetic assessment. Ecohydrology, 10(4):e1838.
Liu X D, Sun G, Mitra B, et al. 2018. Drought and thinning have limited impacts on evapotranspiration in a managed pine plantation on the southeastern United States coastal plain. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 262:14-23.
Mcvicar T R, Li L T, Van Niel T G, et al. 2007. Developing a decision support tool for China's re-vegetation program:simulating regional impacts of afforestation on average annual streamflow in the Loess Plateau. Forest Ecology and Management, 251(1/2):65-81.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment. 2005. Ecosystem and human well-being. Washington DC:Island Press.
National Research Council (NRC). 2001. Basic research opportunities in earth science. Washington:National Academies Press.
Peña-Arancibia J L, van Dijk A I J M, Guerschman J P, et al. 2012. Detecting changes in streamflow after partial woodland clearing in two large catchments in the seasonal tropics. Journal of Hydrology, 416-417:60-71.
Peng S S, Piao S, Zeng Z, et al. 2014. Afforestation in China cools local land surface temperature. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(8):2915-2919.
Sahin V, Hall M J. 1996. The effects of afforestation and deforestation on water yields. Journal of Hydrology, 178(1/4):293-309.
Salemi L F, Groppo J D, Trevisan R, et al. 2012. Riparian vegetation and water yield:a synthesis. Journal of Hydrology, 454-455:195-202.
Stednick J D. 1996. Monitoring the effects of timber harvest on annual water yield. Journal of Hydrology, 176(1/4):79-95.
Sun G, Zhou G Y, Zhang Z Q, et al. 2006. Potential water yield reduction due to forestation across China. Journal of Hydrology, 328(3):548-558.
Sweeney B W, Newbold J D. 2014. Streamside forest buffer width needed to protect stream water quality, habitat, and organisms:a literature review. JAWRA Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 50(3):560-84.
Toohey R C, Boll J, Brooks E S, et al. 2018. Effects of land use on soil properties and hydrological processes at the point, plot, and catchment scale in volcanic soils near Turrialba, Costa Rica. Geoderma, 315:138-148.
Vose J M, Sun G, Ford C R, et al. 2011. Forest ecohydrological research in the 21st century:what are the critical needs?. Ecohydrology, 4(2):146-58.
Wang S, Fu B J, He C S, et al. 2011. A comparative analysis of forest cover and catchment water yield relationships in northern China. Forest Ecology and Management, 262(7):1189-1198.
Wei X H, Liu W F, Zhou P C. 2013. Quantifying the Relative Contributions of forest change and climatic variability to hydrology in large watersheds:a critical review of research methods. Water, 5(2):728-746.
Wei X H, Zhang M F. 2010. Quantifying streamflow change caused by forest disturbance at a large spatial scale:a single watershed study. Water Resources Research, 46(12):W12525.
Wilk J, Andersson L, Plermkamon V. 2001. Hydrological impacts of forest conversion to agriculture in a large river basin in northeast Thailand. Hydrological Processes, 15(14):2729-2748.
Yan J H, Li K, Wang W T, et al. 2015. Changes in dissolved organic carbon and total dissolved nitrogen fluxes across subtropical forest ecosystems at different successional stages. Water Resources Research, 51(5):3681-3694.
Zhang A J, Zhang C, Fu G B, et al. 2012a. Assessments of impacts of climate change and human activities on runoff with SWAT for the Huifa River Basin, northeast China. Water Resources Management, 26(8):2199-2217.
Zhang M F, Wei X H, Sun P S, et al. 2012b. The effect of forest harvesting and climatic variability on runoff in a large watershed:the case study in the Upper Minjiang River of Yangtze River basin. Journal of Hydrology, 464-465:1-11.
Zhang M F, Liu N, Harper R, et al. 2017. A global review on hydrological responses to forest change across multiple spatial scales:Importance of scale, climate, forest type and hydrological regime. Journal of Hydrology, 546:44-59.
Zhou G Y, Wei X H, Chen X Z, et al. 2015. Global pattern for the effect of climate and land cover on water yield. Nature Communications, 6:5918.
Zhou G Y, Wei X H, Luo Y Q, et al. 2010. Forest recovery and river discharge at the regional scale of Guangdong Province, China. Water Resources Research, 46(9):5109-5115.

[1]	吴林川, 王冬梅, 任远, 张丹丹, 黄端. 漓江水陆交错带4种草本覆盖对地表径流氮素的消减作用[J]. 林业科学, 2018, 54(5): 168-176.
[2]	王明玉, 王百田. 不同水土保持措施对黄土高原小流域年径流和产沙的影响——以平凉纸坊沟为例[J]. 林业科学, 2016, 52(8): 10-20.
[3]	牛赟, 刘贤德, 敬文茂, 车宗玺, 赵维俊. 祁连山排露沟流域气温、冻土冻融与河川径流特征[J]. 林业科学, 2014, 50(1): 27-31.
[4]	王金叶, 李海防, 段文军, 唐东明, 王绍能, 刘兴伟, 黄华乾. 漓江上游森林小流域径流过程及其影响因素[J]. 林业科学, 2013, 49(6): 149-153.
[5]	邱治军;周光益;吴仲民;邹滨;罗鑫华. 粤北杨东山常绿阔叶次生林林冠截留特征[J]. 林业科学, 2011, 47(6): 157-161.
[6]	张赟齐;曾玲梅;王陆军;徐小牛. 安徽老山亚热带常绿阔叶林降雨中的养分动态[J]. 林业科学, 2011, 47(12): 143-148.
[7]	刘文彬;蔡体久;琚存勇;姚月锋. 1981-2003年黑龙江省植被变化及其对气候的响应[J]. 林业科学, 2010, 46(6): 154-160.
[8]	裴铁璠;金昌杰;王本楠;刘家冈. 自相似河网的降雨-径流响应——一种函数递归迭代算法[J]. 林业科学, 2010, 46(12): 36-41.
[9]	张胜利;. 秦岭火地塘林区森林生态系统对降水中重金属的作用[J]. 林业科学, 2009, 12(11): 55-62.
[10]	赵雨森辛颖曾凡锁. 阿什河源头水源涵养林在水分传输过程中对水质的影响*[J]. 林业科学, 2008, 44(6): 5-9.
[11]	李纪元肖青李辛雷李锦明鲁仪增. 不同套种模式油茶幼林水土流失及养分损耗[J]. 林业科学, 2008, 44(4): 167-172.
[12]	邓湘雯康文星田大伦项文化闫文德. 不同年龄阶段杉木人工林生态系统的径流规律[J]. 林业科学, 2007, 43(06): 1-6.
[13]	康文星邓湘雯赵仲辉. 林冠截留对杉木人工林生态系统物质循环的影响[J]. 林业科学, 2006, 42(12): 1-5.
[14]	肖胜叶功富倪志荣吴锡麟陈杰. 应用卫星遥感影像分析厦门市地表植被变化[J]. 林业科学, 2003, 39(zk): 128-133.
[15]	田大伦项文化康文星. 湖南第2代杉木幼林的水文学过程及养分动态研究[J]. 林业科学, 2001, 37(3): 64-71.